Tuesday, August 15, 2023

Puzzle #576 - Tapa (Line)

Serkan posed a challenge to create a 10x10 Tapa Line (Tapa rules + 4 shaded cells in a row is banned) puzzle with as large of an empty space as possible. After the obvious degenerate case of a single shaded cell clued with just one row and column, a couple people tried making serious puzzles. An 8x8 empty middle was found pretty quickly, but I felt 8x9 would be possible. And it was.

The tiebreaker was to be the lowest sum of clues, so a few values are lower than they otherwise need to be. I also showcased a degenerate case that would allow for an arbitrarily large empty region on arbitrarily large grids, even with the constraint that every row and column must have a shaded cell. Really, there is no good formulation of an optimization challenge like this that doesn't end up with a degenerate puzzle allowed!

Tuesday, August 1, 2023

Puzzles #574 & #575 - Tilted Squares (Akari, Choco Banana)

The djmathman was streaming one or two weekends ago, and people were jokingly making meme tilted square puzzles. I contributed one of those but then decided no, I'm going to make something legitimate. So I made an Akari (always a flexible choice) and a Choco Banana (one of dj's favorite genres) that I'd somehow never made one of before? It's a fun genre but man is it hard to get started with this theme.


Monday, July 31, 2023

Puzzle #573 - People Do Read These? (Akari)

I recently caught up on logic race in Puzzlers Club, after falling very far behind. In one of my comments I wondered if anyone was actually checking 2 months of backlog and said that the first person to send me a screenshot of a comment would get a puzzle. ft029 was very prompt on this and I didn't have a puzzle planned, and they thought that it was pre-made, so... asked for an Akari. So I made an FT Akari.

Sunday, July 30, 2023

Puzzle #572 - Pairs (Slitherlink)

Lately, djmathman has been making some large Nikoli-style Slitherlink puzzles. I decided to try to make a puzzle that had a bit more flow and a bit less bite to it than my usual puzzles, and what easier starting point is there than a 33 in a corner? The rest of the puzzle made itself, though I did tweak it several times to reduce the difficulty of the middle and emphasize a logically flowing theme throughout.

Saturday, July 29, 2023

Puzzle #571 - Outside the Box (Masyu)

I was in a call with some friends playing Viewfinder when one of them joked that they were going to make a non-unique Masyu in the game. So I made a unique Masyu puzzle.

I started from the central ring (which makes a unique puzzle on its own on 2x2, 4x4 or 6x6) and then tried to find interesting ways to break up the pattern. I really like what I ended up finding here, especially in terms of logic. I really should make more puzzles with denser cluing like this, when the denser cluing has a good reason to be there...

Friday, July 28, 2023

Puzzle #570 - Time for Slitherlink

After the Pentominous puzzles, a little while later I decided to make a small Slitherlink puzzle. I wanted to have a sparser kind of layout than my usual with no "free" openings - I didn't completely succeed there as there's still one common pattern present, but this probably ended up making the puzzle nicer overall.

Thursday, July 27, 2023

Puzzles #568 & #569 - Bite-Sized Pentominous

A while back DireKrow was making 6x6 region division examples, and said they'd had trouble making a good one for Pentominous. That seemed really interesting to me as I hadn't worked with walls in the grid for Pentominous before, and I ended up finding a pretty cool layout that showcased every rule the type has, I think?

I then continued experimenting with 6x6 puzzles and decided to copy the style of Menderbug, with the slanted diagonal. This one is pretty tricky!

Wednesday, July 26, 2023

Puzzles #564 - #567 - Turing Test (Nurikabe)

chaotic_iak's definition of a puzzle came up again as a topic of discussion. I very, very strongly disagree with some of the points in here, especially about excluding puzzles that are generated that meet every other requirement. (I also disagree that something can subjectively be treated as puzzle or not-puzzle based on perceived quality, though I acknowledge that this critiques are much more leveled at logic puzzles than other sorts of puzzles.) The final point in the human authorship section is this: 

"I'm willing to call these computer-assisted puzzles puzzles."
This distinction feels almost entirely meaningless to me, and I set out with an experiment to try to prove it. The thing I really dislike about this is that the exact same puzzle is considered a puzzle if it was made one way, and not if it was considered another way. And if including such a "puzzle?" in a scenario like this makes it one, when in some cases all I did was generate a puzzle and include the first one I got with no assistance or curation... then how would that be different than someone generating that puzzle and solving it?

Tuesday, July 25, 2023

Puzzle #563 - Continuing a Trend (Light and Shadow)

This Light and Shadow puzzle actually continued three trends. One, me making Light and Shadow puzzles because they're fun. Two, Rever made a bunch of puzzles with this clue layout in a variety of types which were pretty neat. Three, while hanging out with both Rever and jkitty in VC we started toying with other genres for this layout and, since Light and Shadow had been a recent thing to try, jkitty tried and didn't think it would work too well. So I took a stab at it and made this in about 5 minutes. To be fair, though, I'd already made the previous 5 puzzles which really helped pinpoint a potential starting point, and I did get a bit lucky with the ending working within the constraints of the start.

If this post goes up and there's not a link to Rever's puzzles with the same layout then remind me to link it or bug them to archive their puzzles somewhere already they're too nice to lose to the harsh void of time.

Monday, July 24, 2023

Puzzles #561 & #562 - The Compromise and The Uncompromising (Light and Shadow)

Here are two Light and Shadow I made, one compromising on the theme (6 and ? antisymmetry) and one where I didn't (the only white clues being the six 7s in a hexagon). The latter puzzle is probably the best Light and Shadow I've ever made and I put a lot of effort into both finding a novel (to me) break-in with the layout, and ensuring the rest of the fill didn't trivialize it along the way. As often happens, I later found that my start would render the end unworkable, but by tweaking the start slightly in a way that expanded the logic I could affect the later parts to give new options that did end up working out.